While scrolling through Rolling Stone's list of "The 50 Best Albums of 2008" I came upon something I found pretty surprising. Chinese Democracy, the first Guns N' Roses album in seventeen(!) years, was rated at number twelve of fifty. Does it really deserve such a high spot?
There's no doubt that Axl Rose tried. He used marketing techniques: he had an exclusive retail agreement with Best Buy for the CD's release, and also contributed the track "Shackler's Revenge" to Rock Band 2. Some of the singles released have done considerably well. "Better," perhaps the most radio-worthy of the bunch, reached eighteenth on the Mainstream Rock Chart.
Other reactions to the album though have been mixed. The disc has sold slowly since it's release, and will not even come close to the sales of previous GN'R work. It has received a sixty-five on Metacritic, meaning most found it good, if a little disappointing. The twelfth best album of the year is a little much. Why not somewhere around twenty-five or thirty? I think that would be more fitting.
The Hobbit Review
12 years ago